So What?
Technology might help accelerate meditation. But the only answer on offer is more mystery.
Sometimes, pivot points arrive in the very beginning of a meditation practice. Sometimes, it can take a decade. Or more. New technologies are on the horizon that hope to accelerate this whole business of deepening meditation practice. Perhaps brain stimulation can help. Or more sophisticated ways of matching people with practices most likely to work for them. But if we succeed in making some benefits of deep meditation more accessible, will we also make the risks more common? Does accelerating meditation even make sense?
No matter how quickly we learn to accelerate ourselves into pivot points, all these experiences, no matter how blissful or insightful, come to an end. What remains? In their wake, the enduring question appears to be something like: How much mystery can you bear?
Transcript
Carla: So I could feel the presence of all the people. Everybody on the earth. It was so weird, and what was crazy was all of a sudden, like, my eyes open and I was just like basking in this insane love for everyone, for the whole experience on this planet.
But so what, that's my big question all the time. So what. So I had like the explosive love experience, you know, so what.
How does that change somebody's life?
Throughout this series, I've described pivot points as someone's first transformative meditation experience. But something that almost everyone reported is that whatever happens during these experiences, it always comes to an end. And usually pretty quickly. No matter how explosive the love or bliss, no matter how deeply your awareness unhooks from its habits, everyone winds up back on the doorstep of their familiar selves.
So what's actually transformative about a pivot point? What, if anything, actually changes? Are they just flashes of experience that disappear without a trace, or do they leave a mark?
I'm Oshan Jarow, and this is the final episode of Pivot Points.
Remember the journalist Claudia, who had that experience of the little person sitting behind her eyeballs, anchoring her first-person perspective, getting knocked loose and sinking back to join what she described as the cavernous blackness of the rest of her being? For a few days afterwards, she felt incredible.
Claudia: I would just be like walking around in my house and like looking at trees and just felt like this incredible sense of oneness, which sounds like cringe and dumb, but that's how it felt. And yeah, I said this afterglow that lasted days.
The afterglow faded, but something did stick around.
Claudia: I would describe it as a shift that anchored a permanent change. I didn't remain in that kind of like, very enhanced state of just crying with joy. Like I don't wake up on a Monday morning crying tears of joy, maybe one day. But having that felt embodied experience of it gave me this permanent shift where I've ever since just. Just kind of held the sense of like self just a lot more lightly. I just feel that sense of like my identity as a separate person. I just feel it's a bit lighter. I feel I can take it a bit less seriously and I feel I can take the world a bit less personally.
A similar thing happened to Max, who we met in episode two when he stumbled into the tingling pleasure of the first jhana while driving. Subsequently, he went on a meditation retreat, and he described this same kind of afterglow.
Max: You get like this floating on cloud nine kind of quality, where suddenly you are at work and it's super stressful, but you're not buffered by it at all. You're just floating through the world and seeing the birds up in the trees and it's just very nice. Like for the first, I think day and a half or so after retreat, I had a very hard time To not chatting up random strangers at the airport and stuff like that. That was a bit of a harsh come down. But I still felt like traces of that openness of that like just extreme ease, just suffusing my day-to-day life.
I was suddenly, worry-free and happy in a way that I hadn't been really before.
Cloud nine didn't last forever, but something subtle had changed.
Max: There's a definite difference between before and after in the sense that, at least for my feeling of what normalcy meant in terms of psychological health and, how easy life can feel and how happy one can be on average. Like that kind of changed.
I heard this same pattern over and over again. The most intense features of someone's pivot point, that part of the experience always came to an end. No one's pivot point just permanently locked them into a perpetual state of bliss or non-dual selfless awareness. But there were often subtler lasting changes, like the sense of levity or ease that Claudia and Max described.
That said, there were interesting exceptions. My favorite example was from the engineering professor, Sean. He had that experience of losing a sense of self while walking along the Charles River.
Sean: It was an extremely positive element in the sense that I really just love understanding how the world or the universe or life works. And this was a huge clicking of like, ah, there. But to be frank about it in terms of practical utility to my life, almost zero. It's like this fun party trick. He said it's one that I can't even show someone else 'cause it's purely subjective. So it's a fun party trick that no one else can even see. It's really interesting. It's deeply satisfying because it starts to connect some dots that I've had my whole life that I haven't been able to figure out how to connect, but hasn't actually changed much of anything about my lived experience.
Except one thing did change, and pretty significantly. He started meditating a lot more. So much so that he started putting fake meetings on his calendar just to make sure he got the time to meditate. And this motivation spike is one of the most common effects I heard across all the different stories. After a pivot point, people get really excited to meditate. There's this breathless sense of discovery. Something is happening in their meditation practice that they really want to explore.
Emily: That like really kickstarted me to just do more as much, much more meditation as I could.
Santtu: Without that experience, I probably would not have taken up two hours per day of sitting afterwards and would not have stuck with it.
Colin: And it sort of gets a snowball effect, right? Quite quickly. Like, it's interesting, and then you wanna do more, and it gets, more interesting, and you wanna do more, and it gets sort of self-reinforcing.
There was something really interesting about the flavor of motivation that spiked after a pivot point. It wasn't just more willpower for people to discipline themselves into meditating more. The motivation came from a shift in how they thought about their practice, the kind of thing that their practice was. It was like meditation went from a chore to an adventure. People who started with an abstract idea that they should or ought to meditate because they've been told it's good for them came out with a curiosity that made them genuinely excited to meditate.
And this is where I started to see what I mentioned at the end of last episode, pivot points as the beginnings of what meditators call a path Meditators have described practice as a path for millennia. The Buddha himself taught meditation as one part of the Eightfold Path towards enlightenment. And that tells us something about why Buddhists caution against these flashy and potentially distracting experiences like pivot points Distractions from what? The path. You're supposed to keep moving towards enlightenment, not go off on some side quest of blissful altered states.
This is the way that Matt, the Midwestern lawyer we've heard from, learned after studying with Buddhist teachers.
Matt: These big experiences are both important and unimportant. It's important because you can see it, you know, the proof of the pudding is in the eating. And you've tasted it. I think it's good because it shows you the possibility of what experience can be. I've heard them explained as, they're like signposts. You're, you're driving somewhere and you see a sign and you go into Albuquerque and the sign says, Albuquerque, 50 miles this way. So, that's good. You're getting closer to Albuquerque. And then Albuquerque, 25 miles away. You don't get out of the car and then grab the sign and then try to try to hold onto it in perpetuity.
It's just saying, you know, if they arise, you're going the right way. So I think that it's important and it's incredibly motivating. But it's also can be just another thing to clinging onto.
The majority of people I interviewed were not Buddhists, and they didn't go into having their pivot points already thinking of meditation in terms of being a path.
And yet, the experiences they had still tended to point beyond themselves. Sometimes people do get fixated on having the same experience, the same pivot point again and again, though usually that burns itself out. But more often, pivot points created an interest in what more experience could become, what else meditation could do. People came out of Pivot Points with a sense of wanting to go explore, with a sense that there is a path to go explore.
Alejandro: It's almost like you were in a beautiful cave, like surrounded with, you know, treasure and all this stuff, but you were only got to be there for a couple minutes, you know, you wanna go in there and see what else is there.
That was a Kansas-based DJ named Alejandro. And notice that the thing he's picking out is not the treasure he found in the experience he had. It was his curiosity as to what else is in the cave.
Claudia discussed her experience with a teacher at a local zendo and came away with a similar feeling.
Claudia: He was like, imagine there's this massive, massive, massive pane of glass that's all fogged up. You've just rubbed a little corner in this foggy pane of glass and now that's clear. And he was like, now your job is to rub more of the pane of glass and more of the pane of glass and more of the pane of glass.
And I found that super helpful because I was like, okay, cool. Like I had been fortunate enough to kind of like stumble into this amazing experience and now my job is to just keep trying with it.
She picked up that same open-ended interest and told me that from there on, she started sitting for 30 minutes a day just to see what happens. And again, with Tobin, the exterminator living out in British Columbia.
Tobin: After that it was, curiosity took me. I was wanting to learn everything I could. I'd realized that I've learned something that I assumed I already knew. I assumed I was completely aware of how my body was and how my, my mind worked and where my, what my experience was like. So I realizing that there was another way of approaching my experience, I got very fascinated and I needed to I needed to explore it as much as I could.
These experiences didn't create mild curiosities. The sense of a path and a more exploratory relationship to meditation also has this quality of depth and importance. It feels significant. Here's Stuart, the UK-based filmmaker.
Stuart: It felt to me as though what I had experienced was very authentic and very sincere. I really would say that it was as though from that point onwards, I thought this. Will inevitably be a sort of facet of my existence. A component of my main interest will be exploring why this was the way it was and so I just launched into the practice. And yeah, and then it's led me down this path over the last sort of six years.
If I had another five episodes, we could look at where these paths seem to go and what other treasures people do find out in those beautiful caves. But in terms of pivot points, what matters is that they're inaugural experiences. They recast the whole project of meditation as doing something or going somewhere that just wasn't on your map of the mind beforehand.
If you have a pivot point that launches you into the world of deep meditation, the whole thing seems to open up. Motivation swells, intrigue abounds, a path appears. But tens of millions of Americans try meditation every year, and far more across the Western world, and we do not have millions of meditators experiencing pivot points.
Instead, the terrain of beginner's meditation, as we've heard, can feel like a boring or difficult chore.
Sometimes people have pivot points pretty quickly, and sometimes it could take years.
Matt: But I would say at least for the first five years, meditation was difficult, it was boring, it was not fun. Going through those beginner stages was really difficult and I really salute anybody who can do that. 'cause it's very hard.
Richard: For some people, it can take decades. Then you need patience. You need to keep showing up.
Which means that one of the most common outcomes among people who pick up a meditation practice is that they give it up before anything really compelling or profound happens. And this isn't a new or uniquely Western situation. Probably for as long as humans have been meditating, the majority of people's experiences have not penetrated into the deep end.
Michael: We know historically this is just not for everyone. The media kind of makes it sound like everyone needs some mindfulness and sure a little bit of mindfulness, that could help. But I would say that people who are gonna go to that second thing and say, huh, there's something interesting here.
Beyond just stress reduction. That's like one or 2% maybe. That's what we see over and over again. It's a very, very tiny sliver of humanity that is going to give a fuck about this.
Which is why I think it's actually a really interesting thing that the West has begun to ask a quintessentially Western question of meditation.
Can we make the benefits of deep meditation more accessible by speeding the whole thing up?
Can we use technology to accelerate the road to a pivot point?
There have been media headlines in the past about using technology to, quote, "hack enlightenment," to speed run the entire path of Buddhist meditation, and that hasn't panned out so far, and I'm skeptical it ever will. But what does seem possible, and what is actually being worked on by a number of organizations and researchers right now, is using technology to get people from never having meditated into their first taste of the deep end or their first pivot point quicker.
Kati: I've been talking about this for years. Like this is one of the dreams of my life is to, is to have something that I've been calling with the super catchy name of a practice matcher.
Here's Kati Devaney, the neuroscientist and research director at the Consciousness Foundation.
Kati: What I would love to have is just a giant database of all these different paths up the mountain. And then when someone new, comes to practice for whatever their reason is, either I'm suffering, I'm curious, I wanna get enlightened, I just wanna feel better in my family. There could be a say an initial sort of scan and then a result that says, oh, you have the type of psychobiological system that other people like you have benefited from doing a lot of ecstatic dance and then a sitting practice or other people like you have benefited from, starting with psychedelics and then moving into a movement practice and you should not do a sitting still practice for a while.
And being able to have that kind of, almost like a sorting hat for practitioners.
This kind of pluralism in meditation practice, the idea that you can choose from among a variety of practices depending on your own context and goals to best suit your needs, Kati explained that this is a pretty new thing. This is something that's relatively unique and exciting about the Western culture of meditation.
Kati: And that was the great thing about being in this historical moment that we're in, is that, all of us have access to all of these things that were typically, what you had access to was just what the people around you were doing. There was the practice of your culture and that was it.
In some ways that practice was pre-matched to you because it was developed in the culture that you were situated in. And we've lost that. But what we've gained is the ability to have something that's incredibly personalized. But it could be so much better than it is now.
Remember that we've already heard stories of people starting out with styles of meditation that just did not work for them. For example, Sean.
Sean: I tried meditation many times before that because I knew that, okay, this is the way to study your mind. But it was always the watch the breath for an hour. And I just bounced off of that I think it was mostly sold as there's a way to improve focus to, have better emotional regulation, all good things, but not what I was trying to get out of it. And so for it to feel like it wasn't directly getting at what I wanted and also for the actual exercise to just feel, to be blunt, really boring and frustrating, and there to be no apparent feedback loop of this is doing something, I couldn't stick with it.
Kati's idea is basically a massive database that would let us find correlations between types of people and types of practices, so that maybe when Sean first started meditation, he could have been told that based on past experiences of people with his disposition and goals, and maybe even patterns of brain activity, meditating on the breath for an hour probably won't be a super effective practice. That perhaps inquiry-based practices, like what he eventually picked up through the Waking Up app, would be more effective for someone like him.
I heard something similar from Lars Sandved-Smith, the neuroscientist we met back in the third episode.
Lars: What you're talking about, is, I think one of the, one of the great promises of this work.
Lars thinks we might be able to get more precise than just a database of correlations. He and his colleagues are developing mathematical models of the mind based on those theories of predictive processing and active inference we heard about. Which basically means they have a bunch of equations that describe what the mind does at a general level. The equations provide a model of the mind.
Lars: So what we can do is take one of these models and fit an individual's data to the model, and then that model is gonna tell us something about… How does this person account for uncertainty? How does this person allocate their attention? And given that. Now taking that fitted model and running the simulation towards awakening gives you a kind of intervention for that individual. And maybe it looks like meditation, maybe it looks like something else.
Once you've plugged in someone's psychological details, you could basically run the numbers on those equations to get a recommendation for the most effective kind of practice for that individual.
Lars: I think that's a really, beautiful thing that might come of this is that for so many of us, if you find yourself in a community doing a style of practice that just doesn't work for you, you can spend decades just digging wells that never hit water, and all it would take is just finding the style of practice that works for you. And it could just be right around the corner and you could, you could break through in, in, in very little time. And a deeper understanding of the mechanisms behind all of that would, facilitate that whole process.
So all this gave me another way to think about pivot points.
Pivot points are moments where the practice you're doing clicks into place with your psychology. It's a burst of feedback that tells you the well you're digging with your practice has struck something.
When I started researching the acceleration part of this project, I assumed I'd wind up focusing on brain stimulation. People have been building different kinds of brain stimulation technologies focused on meditation or just spiritual experiences in general, for decades now, and there have been a few flashes of interesting results, but nothing all that exciting has made it through the hype. When I asked Lars about the brain stimulation stuff, he kind of sighed.
Lars: You know, it's funny, I've been in this space for long enough to meet, some of the more senior, contemplative neuroscience researchers at different conferences and things. And there's this arc that, a lot of researchers seem to go through in this space from.
Oh my God. We're right around the corner to a science of awakening. And this is gonna give rise to a technology that will allow awakening at scale like we have never seen before. And we are just going to understand how it works and why it works, engineer it, and boom, everybody just come into the awakening booth and walk out a bodhisattva. Like the future is bright. And then things sort of dry up and the problem seems harder than expected. And then the researchers end up just kind of, actually I'm not meeting them at conferences anymore. I'm meeting them at retreat centers and they're, they're not really trying to build technology anymore.
They're just sort of going back to the source and sitting with great teachers. And have kind of given up on that project. And there's like two ways you could interpret that. One way is to say, there's something deeply misguided or flawed in the notion of engineering, awakening tech. The other thing you could say is, well, they're just too early. And, actually it's a harder problem than originally thought. And I think it's somewhere in between. I am optimistic about the potential for technology to facilitate awakening. But I definitely see it more like playing the role of having good nutrition when you go into the gym, you know, you still gotta go to the gym and do the work, but, you know, eating well helps.
I think we're still very early in our understanding of how technology can play a healthy role in supporting or deepening a meditation practice. And at the moment, there's still a growing variety of potential avenues, potential technologies that could prove helpful. For example, one that I'm really interested in is being very slowly and patiently researched at the University of Arizona's SEMA Lab or Science Enhanced Mindful Awareness Lab. They're working on targeted ultrasound brain stimulation, where they basically pulse ultrasound waves at a hub of the brain's default mode network in an effort to get people into deeper states of meditation more quickly. And their first paper reporting on those results just came out last year and looked pretty good.
The ultrasound did seem to help novice meditators get from the early stages of drowning in incessant thoughts to a more calm state of equanimity quicker.
When I asked Lars, he was actually excited by a different technology.
Lars: I've tried them all. I've tried the ultrasound, I've tried the biofeedback, I've tried tDCS, the one bit I'm actually quite curious about and kind of cautiously exploring is, photobiomodulation.
I recently purchased a Vielight headset, and have been practicing with that and been finding that really powerful actually.
Is that infrared, does that actually look like in practice?
Lars: It looks like a headset, with infrared LEDs, that are shining, a frequency of light that you're getting when you walk outside in the sun. I mean, it's, as far as I understand, it's very, very safe. And that just phenomenologically, what I find when I practice with that is like, it's as if I'm at the end of a retreat quite quickly in terms of just like the energy and the kind of ability to let go of tensions that I hadn't even noticed before kind of thing. So I think it's quite interesting and I, and I kind of think it's also there's like a plausible, mechanism of action there.
And it seems to kind of work. And I also think it might have potential for giving people an experience. We've been talking about, you galvanizing this faith, like kind of giving people a sense. And it was interesting actually, just anecdotally, my wife, first time she tried it, what she said afterwards was, you know, I haven't experienced a quiet like that since we were, in India since, because we were like really practicing and really going forward there. And like, it's just, you know, you'd forgotten what that could be like. And not even being aware of the places that one can reach with meditation that like, you know, you say to people like, you know, meditate because you know it's gonna, you know, make you feel better and calmer and stuff.
Like, well, I feel better, I'm pretty calm. Like, you don't even have a sense of how calm it's possible to be, or how open or how lucid or how peaceful, how joyful, how loving, like it's not even there. And so something that just gives you a taste could be really powerful. And for her it's really, you know rekindled her desire to, to sit.
It kind of seems to me like we've moved from the old idea of a full-on awakening helmet to more just a helmet that can kind of help out a little bit and mostly at first?
Lars: Yeah, exactly. It feels a bit like training wheels in a bit, like kinda like I'm being pulled subtly in the direction and I'm, I've still had to figure out how to let go into it and that's kind of always been the case, but it just a little bit of, a little bit of help. So who knows?
At this point, we just don't know if using infrared light helmets or ultrasound brain stimulation will wind up proving helpful and safe for meditation at scale. Maybe 50 years from now, in the same way that today we might think of monasteries and robes and singing bowls as the paraphernalia of deep meditation, future generations will think of practice-matching algorithms and ultrasound headsets and maybe even psychedelics in similar ways. But say that does all happen. Say we get really good at speeding meditators from complete beginners into the deeper terrain that pivot points open up.
Then whatever risks come along with deep meditation, those will be amplified, too.
Kati, who's also a meditation teacher, mentioned something interesting. She's noticed a relationship between how deep of a meditation experience someone has and how psychologically prepared they are to handle and integrate that experience.
Kati: This is something I notice in a lot of my students also. There's a deeper wisdom that's often online in practice, which is about what's the level of insight that's safe to have right now? Like what can the container hold and the container of your own mind and then the container of the retreat you're on and all the psychological stuff you're bringing to it.
The teacher Richard Shankman describes something similar. He works a lot with concentration practices where people report those big blissful experiences.
Richard: A lot of people think, oh, that's what I would want. That sounds great, but it's got its downside because the concentration can get ahead of, how much they've unwound their own psychology and somatic in the body and everything. And that can lead to certain challenges. It can be too much overwhelming. So things can start to blow open in a way, that you may not have built up the resources to work with, or you might not have worked it out in gradual steps to get to the deeper states.
All of which is to say, it's not necessarily a good thing to just blast a beginner into a pivot point right off the bat. The better we get at zipping and zapping people into these transformative experiences, the better we ought to be at recognizing when that's actually going to be safe and beneficial, and supporting the people who inevitably have difficulties.
Now, again, let's say that all happens. We develop all kinds of accelerating technology and all sorts of know-how around how to use it safely.
Remember that every teacher we heard from last episode recommended that as we focus more on pivot points, we shouldn't get caught up in the desire to have them. When we actually sit and meditate, we need to be able to give up any hope of having an experience other than what's already actually happening. As meditation teacher Tina Rasmussen put it…
Tina: Cause the minute we're trying to get somewhere, we're not in the present moment. All the good stuff is in the present moment.
The mentality of trying to accelerate and optimize meditation practice to have pivot points faster can be in direct conflict with actually deepening your practice. If we get too caught up in searching for ways to have different experiences than what we're already having, it can be difficult to let that go when you sit down on the meditation cushion. Which is why I really liked how meditation teacher Charlie Awbery described this whole project of acceleration.
Charlie: Yeah, it's so ironic, isn't it? I mean, one of the results is felt sense of not rushing anymore. Of not being forward, end gaining, like trying to get to the thing, but a sense of contented, open, presence. And that is not necessarily, speedy. You know, it strikes me that speed and effectiveness are not all the same thing. You can be highly pragmatic in your practice. You can optimize that process, or at least, get close to having a very fast feedback loop. That is not the same necessarily as looking to see what is most effective in the long run. Maybe we have a tendency to overemphasize the speed aspect.
Like, let's get through this stage quickly, let's get into that next experience. And have that experience next, and have that experience next. But when you relate the experience itself to long-term contexts that provides a richer, more, giving? Giving in the sense of like receptive, relaxed, understanding of what this is about and why. I'm smiling because there's Dzogchen Yogis are always the lazy ones. I'm very definitely a fit. I'm a lazy yogi.
If you remember, we heard Charlie's pivot point at the beginning of last episode. At 22 years old, Charlie goes on a retreat in India just to see what this whole meditation thing is about, and right away on that retreat, they have this completely explosive meditation experience.
And from an acceleration perspective, we might say if you can have a pivot point in your first attempt at meditating, that's a good thing. You're just jumping right into the good stuff. But Charlie subsequently spent months exhausted and depressed and going to see doctors. Eventually, they came back around to meditating and felt that the experience was positive, but it took a long time to get to that place. Ultimately, it's probably easier for someone to embrace a lazy meditation practice when, like Charlie, they had their first pivot point right off the bat. They didn't go through years of boring and dull practice without any suggestion or occasion to believe that something deeper might be available to them.
But this gives us a sense of the tightrope we'll have to walk between the risks and the potential benefits of acceleration. Go too fast and people can get hurt. Go too slow, people get bored.
The idea isn't that technology can or should replace meditation altogether, especially because when talking to advanced meditators, they're not looking for ways to get out of doing the practice or to spend less time meditating. Meditation is something that becomes deeply important and meaningful to them. But often it takes some time for that to happen, and that's where, at their best, I think these acceleration approaches can help. Not as replacements for meditation and not as shortcuts for gaining the benefits of deep meditation without putting in the effort of keeping a regular practice. Although I wouldn't be surprised if we do wind up developing technological shortcuts to some of the benefits.
But at least in my mind, the most interesting and exciting prospect of acceleration is reducing the time it takes for someone to learn how to enjoy and appreciate their practice. To put that a little differently, I think that acceleration technologies could be helpful in reducing the time it takes for meditators to lose interest in acceleration altogether. Acceleration is like a ladder that we want to climb up to the point that we're happy to just kick it aside and enjoy whatever our practice and experience already has to offer.
Matt: I would say it's more about going from goal oriented and I would say to some extent an ego-driven practice, right? Like, I want, I want, to being less goal-oriented, more allowing the practice to unfold spontaneously in the way that it's going to unfold. I mean, you can try to fight against it, but you know, you're fighting against the combined universe, I suppose.
Back in the first episode, I mentioned that I was interested in pivot points as occasions to believe, as experiences that generate a belief in the value of deep meditation practice. Beyond the beginner's mindfulness stuff.
And you can see that start to happen with that sense of a path emerging out of these experiences. There's a sense of something more to be found than just repeating the same experiences over and over.
Henry: It's like you've knocked a hole through a wall now and you can no longer sort of deny that there's something on the other side of the wall that you didn't know about before.
But I also mentioned the role my own doubts have played in the project. I know what the fireworks of access concentration or the first jhana feel like. I know what unhooking from thoughts and certain aspects of the sense of self feel like. What I don't know is what it feels like to come out of these experiences with certainty or even confidence in the value of continuing down the path they suggest. After a meditation experience, I'm usually still left with some version of Carla's "so what" question still nagging at me.
So after spending so much time thinking about pivot points, I wanted to go back to one of the oldest acceleration technologies, a meditation retreat, to see if I could revisit them from one more perspective, my own experience.
And so in the late spring, after wrapping up all my interviews, I traveled to a meditation center outside of Santa Cruz and joined Michael Taft for a seven-day meditation retreat As is common when I go on retreat, I spent the first day or two mostly just sitting there and thinking. By the third day, my legs started to hurt. And I mean really hurt. I was dreading every session. So I tried focusing on the pain like we heard so many others do. Maybe I'd find a way to transform the pain into pleasure.
Unfortunately, I had no such luck. I was just really aware of the pain in my legs. But by around the fifth day, the worst of it had passed. I think my body gave up on trying to get me to move, and I also started mixing in a few different postures. And I found that all that focusing on the pain had helped to bring me into a pretty concentrated state.
And what usually happens when I'm in a nice groove of concentration is that I have this feeling of melting into a really spacious expanse. It's like a big void with no boundaries and nothing inside of it. It's nothing revolutionary, but it is pleasant and it is relaxing. And I've often thought of this empty void as what meditation teachers mean when they talk about awareness. Michael's whole meditation instruction is basically about recognizing awareness and then just resting in that recognition. So on the afternoon sit of the fifth day, I'm settling into my spacious expanse, and this thought popped up.
Whatever this comfortable void is, it's not awareness. Because I could literally see it. It looked like the night sky without any stars. But non-dual teachers are always confusingly pointing out that awareness is not something you can see or touch or feel.
So when that thought arose, it was as if it just popped the balloon, and the whole field collapsed. My sense of there being space or time or a self at the center of it all, everything evaporated in an instant. I didn't go unconscious.
There was a complete absence of everything that usually structures my experience, but there was something present. It wasn't something that I could see or feel. I just kind of knew it. It was like this very primitive or fundamental sense of liveliness or awakeness.
There was nothing, but nothing was awake.
And I wasn't having a bunch of insights in the form of words in my head. I just knew immediately that this quality is always there and is something like the raw material out of which my usual experience is built. And while saying that still sounds strange to me, it was interesting to think how similar it was to something that Thomas had mentioned about his experience.
Thomas: And everything, the forest and the baby stroller and the foot and the thought was made of the same essential substance.
As I came out of it, experience returned to its three-dimensional shape. I remembered I was sitting in a room. Sounds and sights and all the works came back online. But all of my usual experiences now had this new strangeness to them. I was noticing that same awake, primitive quality everywhere, and it had the effect of making everything appear just a little more miraculous, for lack of a less embarrassing word. And I understood why meditators leave a retreat and can just look down at a blade of grass or a stone and be in complete awe. Because it doesn't matter what you're looking at, it's the material of perception itself that feels like it's imbued with this quality.
I spent that evening mostly just walking around the grounds, wondering what had happened, kind of confused about what I was seeing. That night, I'm sitting at this little circular table in my room trying to write notes about the experience. After a few failed attempts, I remembered something that the neuroscientist Ruben Laukkonen told me about what to do after the roots of your mind are yanked out of place.
Ruben: When you have a explosive experience, there's a whole process that the mind body system engages in to put everything in its new place. And a lot of this happens naturally in the mind and brain if we allow it to. The brain, even when we're resting, taking shower, sleeping is engaging in model optimization processes. So you can imagine that you've got a set of bowling pins, and this experience has been this kind of bowling ball that's just come through and, knocked over a bunch of pins. But those pins now have to find their place back in a kind of, order. And the brain has really beautiful mechanisms for doing this.
Things like synaptic pruning and then model optimization and so on. And so this takes time. This takes rest. This takes humility. This takes openness because the biggest risk I think, with integration is not so much that integration won't happen. I think it's a very natural process, but that we get in the way of the integration process. Somehow the self models get kind of graspy with the experience that's happened and build a new story, a new narrative to get locked up in. And so my sense with the integration is more that how can we kind of get out the way to allow the integration to take place without jumping to conclusions about our experience without coming up with a new story about who we now think we are or our specialness or so on?
And knowing that our brain and body is a vehicle for that, it's tuned for that. It's tuned to adapt to find a new way of seeing, and all of the kind of confusion will find its place.
I was basically doing the opposite, and not just with my own experience. The whole time I was on the retreat, I'd been thinking about all the stories of pivot points I'd heard and wondering what kind of story corralling them all into one space could tell about meditation.
What should we make of the fact that somebody can concentrate on tingling sensations in their body to the point where a volcano of bliss erupts through their heads?
Or that you can unhook awareness from thoughts, from the body, from the self, and slip into these startlingly rich, meaningful, and expansive configurations of consciousness.
If mindfulness told the story of stress reduction, what story do these experiences tell?
To Ruben's point, it's starting to seem to me that whatever stories we can tell about these experiences are among their least interesting consequences.
One of the functions of a story is to freeze experience. The moment you have a new story to tell about your experience, you've removed the uncertainty that it brought into your world, and that's what the predictive mind evolved to do. It comes up with stories that explain away uncertainty. A pivot point is not actually a moment where your understanding of the world changes. It's just prior to that. It's a moment where your understanding of the world is suspended. Your entire story-making apparatus is temporarily broken by an experience that doesn't fit, and it's that space before a new story takes over, that space in between stories where uncertainty floods in, where we don't know what's happening.
That's the critical moment of a pivot point. And that's why people so often describe the value of pivot points with terms like not knowing, as in the case of Kim.
Kim: A softening into, I don't know. There was just this delightful falling into not knowing.
Or as some kind of mystery in the case of Jay.
Jay: I know it has something to do with tapping into, something primordial, right? Something that defines the very fundamental essence of who we are. And you can use a lot of words to describe that. And the words are always inadequate and certain form of teacher or practitioner might use the word pure awareness or tapping into awareness. But then you could also use the word magic, like tapping into magic or mystery.
There's something to that direct feeling of uncertainty or not knowing or mystery that, as Jay said, feels primordial. It feels fundamental. That's exactly how a psychologist named Nick Bowles described it.
Nicholas: More and more I think about meditation it's connecting into something very fundamental about what it is to be alive. It opens up a lot more questions than it provides answers to. So sitting in with the ambiguity of the unknown nature of what it is to be alive and to be in the circumstance we find ourselves in. It's really difficult because, yeah. How do you articulate the, this kind of opening up into the unknown? And being comfortable with the messiness and just developing a different relationship to the chaotic and, existential challenges that we face, going through this world.
One way to think about that sense of a path that emerges out of these experiences is learning to grow more comfortable in that sense of not knowing, to let it unfold rather than trying to shut it down.
And it seems like the more comfortable we can become in that feeling, the more it opens up.
Tina: I mean, there is a mystery that has unfolded you and me and everyone listening to this your entire life.
Again, Tina Rasmussen.
Tina: And that mystery is trustworthy you know, there's the potential that we can know something about the mystery of existence that the Buddha was pointing to. We can know that for ourselves. Every human being has the potential to know that. And we're opening to the mystery.
And opening is the right word here. There's no single template for what that process feels like. Suspending our usual habits and stories expands the range of what we might experience. So it makes sense that we've heard a pretty wide range of how pivot points actually play out. Maybe you find a sense of healing.
Matt: There is no better medicine that I have found,
Or a feeling of love.
Claudia: My heart space was just like cracking wide open. All I wanted to do was like grab the other people on retreat and be like, I love you.
Maybe you find yourself terrified.
Thomas: Things like condensed and started to feel heavy and I got so scared. This is lights out. What if I never come back?
Maybe you find catharsis.
Mark: I remember one day leaving the meditation hall and going out to the jungle and just like, it's pouring rain and I'm just on the ground sobbing. And when it passed and the rain passed. Feeling, feeling like feeling the transformative power of that.
Or maybe like me, you still can't say all that much about what actually happened.
Aviva: I was thrown into this total different realm where I can just say what I didn't have. I didn't have a body, I didn't have a identity. There was no time, there was no space. There was no thought, there was even no emotion. Somehow it was very, very full. Full of meaning and, and beauty.
The experience I had on retreat didn't settle the question of "so what?" For me. I've still got doubts that come and go.
But since my retreat, the way I think about why I'm meditating has been changing.
I'm not worrying about what I'll get out of it in the long run. I'm meditating because I found something extremely strange in my own direct experience, and I want to explore that. Every time I sit down, I just let my mind go slack, and that quality I mentioned comes into varying degrees of focus. I have no idea where that might lead, but that doesn't really matter.
And that's how I'm starting to think about pivot points in general. They seem to offer many things, but answers are not one of them.
Clarity about the world of deep meditation is not one of them.
When I started working on this project, I thought of the obscurity that surrounds the world of deep meditation as a problem.
I thought of mystery as the end of inquiry.
And instead, I think I'm realizing that pivot points have a way of turning a felt sense of mystery into the beginning of a path of practice.
And the value of that path, the value of deep meditation, is going to remain somewhat obscure, because what seems to matter most about these experiences is precisely what cannot be said.
As always, if you wanna learn more about the series, read transcripts, find guest information, discover bonus episodes, you can head over to pivotpoints.xyz.
If you enjoyed the series and wanna stay in the loop on similar projects in the future, you can sign up for my newsletter at heretodisappear.org.
And if you'd like to support more projects like this, you can either become a paid subscriber of that newsletter or just share this series with a friend who you think might get a kick out of it.
Pivot Points was made possible by an incredible cast of supporters. The team at the Waking Up meditation app, editing by Amy Standen, original theme music by Marcus Bagala, cover art by Valero Doval, audio engineering by Lucas Del Calvo, and the generous meditators, scientists, and teachers who took the time to share their stories and insights. Thank you all.