Holy Crap This Is Real
There’s a great variety of transformative meditation experiences.
Sometimes, the familiar anchors of experience — self, space, time — go missing for a little while. Other times, bliss erupts throughout awareness. Or buried emotions rise to the surface, clearing numbed pathways of feeling. In this episode, we hear directly from meditators themselves. What’s a pivot point like? How do they differ, and what do they all share? How weird are they, really?
Extras
Transcript
Mark: I remember leaving that first retreat opportunity that I was in thinking I've had a transformational experience here. I'm fundamentally different than when I went in. I went in as one thing and I've come out as something else and I'm, I mean, I have to now figure out what this new thing is that I am.
Sean: And then the best way I can describe it is it's like I subjectively disappeared. My subjective experience was one becoming completely experientially transparent. And again, words will fail because it will sound potentially wishy-washy. But I mean, this was a completely lucid and vivid and tangible experience. If you had just dropped me into that moment without context, I would've thought someone had slipped me some kind of drugs or something, right? This was not subtle.
In the last episode, we covered the two worlds of meditation. There's beginner's mindfulness, which has taken Western culture by storm with a focus on stress relief and practical benefits. Then there's the hazier world of deep meditation, where minds are not soothed but transformed. And pivot points are doorways between those two worlds.
In this episode, we're gonna get as close as we can to the inside of pivot points by hearing firsthand from the people who've experienced them.
Thomas: It was a huge shift in my practice.
Alex: And that's what it opened it up for me was showing just that like the things that some people have big claims around or that many of the sages and mystics have big claims around, it's possible.
I'm Oshan Jarow, and this is episode two of Pivot Points.
For this series, I interviewed a whole bunch of meditators. I spoke with people who've been meditating for no more than six months, doing a style they heard about on the internet, all the way to people who have spent decades in traditions like Zen or Vajrayana Buddhism. I spoke with engineers, doctors, an exterminator living in rural British Columbia who meditates in his pickup truck on breaks, an account manager at a chocolate company in London. I did not speak with monks. I spoke with people who have full-time jobs and families and bills to pay, and even with all of that, incredibly powerful meditation experiences.
And while the details of their experiences varied, they all tended to fit into one of two categories. The first were insight experiences. And by insight, I mean a moment where someone sees or notices something about consciousness that's always been available, but they've never noticed it before.
Insight experiences aren't really altered states of consciousness. Nothing changes about the raw data of experience, but the way we process and interpret it does change. What changes is your perspective on experience more than the contents of experience.
And then there are concentration experiences, which are much more like altered states of consciousness. Here, the raw data of experience does change. You experience something beyond the pale of your ordinary experience. And when the experience ends, whatever you were experiencing goes away. Those unusual contents depart.
This taxonomy is actually one of the oldest distinctions in Buddhism between two qualities of mind and styles of meditation known as vipassana, which translates as insight, and shamatha, which is usually translated as either tranquility or concentration. Naturally, there's a long tradition of Buddhists disagreeing with each other about how separable insight and concentration really are, but we'll use the distinction because it's helpful in making sense of the pivot points I heard in my research. Starting with Sean.
Sean: My name is Sean Lubner, 35 years old. I'm an assistant professor at Boston University in material science and engineering. I'd say my whole life, I've just been very naturally and intensely curious about essentially understanding what this is. Like, what is existence, which is what led me originally to study physics. And it's given me a lot of insight into how the universe works. But it's also increasingly left this gap of, subjective experience.
Eventually, I started to realize, okay, the method of objective empirical science, where you're observing from the third person perspective, the apparent world out there, just isn't able to directly capture subjective experience.
For Sean, this is where meditation fits in. Scientists can't look inside of your skull and see exactly how you feel. They can't actually access any consciousness other than their own. But if, like Sean, you're trying to understand how the universe works, consciousness is a pretty important part of the story. So at the very least, you do have direct access to your own mind, and meditation just becomes a way of exploring it directly.
Sean: Eventually. Okay. April, 2021, I found out about the Waking Up app and Sam Harris and that was kinda my entry point. I tried meditation many times before that because I knew that, okay, this is the way to study your mind. But it was always the watch the breath for an hour. And I just bounced off of that. But the Sam Harris approach was the first one that made me realize, ah, meditation can be used as an actual scientific tool of investigation, a methodological way to investigate subjective experience and falsify hypotheses and see what it is. Both the process and the stated goal, changed how I frame my whole approach to it.
Now, this is not about trying to discipline your mind, now it's about, here is your, observatory to your own mind. There are no rules. You don't have to be rigid. It's exploration, it's play. That felt totally different. It really resonated with my natural curiosity rather than drill sergeant, tame your mind approach.
With this new approach to meditation, Sean's practice starts to take off. In our video call, he pulled up his journal and told me the story of his first pivot point.
He'd been meditating daily for about a month, and he boards a flight and decides to meditate, eyes open in his seat.
Sean: Essentially I noticed something. And here I can jump to my journal entry. I basically noticed that I could pay attention to just seeing itself as something entirely separate from thinking, and that the scene itself maybe was what awareness is. So at this point, I heard a lot of people talking about awareness and it, it becomes this really, wishy-washy term, which is frustrating. And there was just this moment of, hang on, there's this aspect of experience that is right there oh, it was not conceptual. That that is probably the most important distinction to make. It had nothing to do with thoughts. And I've heard all of these descriptions before, but there's this, again, frustrating but amusing sense of, oh, this is what people meant.
The shift here wasn't about what Sean was experiencing. What changed was how he was experiencing the same old visual field that's always there. And this first experience, as modest as it may sound, sent Sean's practice into overdrive.
Sean: And after that. I'll just admit, I, I was absolutely just chasing that experience again, which is, I think, a common mistake. And I, I kind of knew that, but I also couldn't not. I was having to actually put on fake meetings in my calendar, right? Because I realized if I saved it for the evening, I'd get distracted. And I wanted to make sure that I had time to spend with my wife. And so I was really brute forcing this into my, my schedule to make it work. But I just kind of, I had to.
And so it was really just, okay, was it because I had gotten this amount of sleep? Was it because I had some caffeine? Was it because I was paying attention to my peripheral vision? Like I, I was really trying to systematically go through and figure out, okay, what made that happen? Which as a side note is maybe a testament to how much it's not conceptual, right? I knew exactly what the experience was, but that alone was completely powerless to, or I was completely powerless to use that to get back to the experience. Because it wasn't about understanding it or figuring it out. It was just something my brain did, or who knows.
Right.
10 months go by this way, with Sean trying and failing to recreate that experience. Until, as all great discoveries seem to go, he went for a walk.
Sean: So I live in Boston and I really enjoy just going for long walks along the Charles River. And it also has become kind of a meditation practice in itself. And what I've been doing, a lot of leading up to that is there's one type of practice called the Headless Way. It sounds completely childish and naive, but that's because it's often misinterpreted to mean something conceptually. It's essentially notice that from your first person, subjective point of view, you don't have a head. Maybe you can kind of see your nose and infer from that, that you have a head, but that's an inference, right? That's conceptual.
You don't actually have a head experientially in your first person perspective. The only way that you know you're, that you have a head is through conceptual inference. Some people bounce off of that because it seems, again, completely silly. Like, of course I have a head. What are you talking about? But the point is to train attention to learn, to make the distinction between what is known conceptually versus what is known directly as experience.
This practice comes from a book published in 1961 by the English philosopher and author Douglas Harding, titled On Having No Head: Zen and the Rediscovery of the Obvious. It's a tiny book. The front cover of the edition that I own has a hole carved out in the shape of a head right at the center, so that as you turn the cover, you can see right through the
Sean: So I was looking out at the water, but there was a road right behind me. And so my attention. Was very intensely focused on the visual field in front of me, the water. But at the same time, my hearing attention was also drawn to the cars behind me. So my attention was kind of being pulled simultaneously in front and behind me and kind of this full three, three-dimensional environments. I think just because I'd been drilling it day in, day out, reflexively attention kind of also looked for like, okay, what's in between in front and behind? But I think, what was important there is it, there was no thought saying, I am going to look for my head.
So it didn't feel like a volitional action. It just happened and there was nothing there. And then the best way I can describe it is it's like I subjectively disappeared.
So I'm not planning anything actually happened in the physical world, but my subjective experience was one, becoming completely experientially transparent.
And again, words will fail because it will sound potentially wishy-washy. But I mean, this was a completely lucid and vivid and tangible experience. If you had just dropped me into that moment without context, I would've thought someone had slipped me some kind of drugs or something, right? This was not subtle. And it lasted maybe 20 seconds, which is not a long time, but it was enough time for me to actually explore it, and I kind of froze. What is going on there is. Just the scene. There's no actual me here and not conceptually. I've had that before. I mean, experientially, there is nothing here. And yeah, that knocked my socks off.
But it's interesting 'cause on one hand. You weren't there. Right. Completely transparent. Yeah. On the other hand, you, you said that, but you were able to explore it. So to, to the degree that it is possible, like what was it like to be inside of that? You weren't there, but you were noticing it. What does this feel like in that moment?
Sean: Yeah, no, these are great questions and trying to talk about these things ends up sounding like so much self contradiction and paradox. So, so please tease it apart is fine.
We expect contradiction.
Sean: Yes, yes. So, so one important point to clarify is that nothing actually changed about the raw data of the visual field, right? People talk about like, oh, the center drops out or feels like I am merged with everything, and, and that's a understandable but completely off base misinterpretation of what is meant, right? It, it, nothing actually changes about the raw data of experience, right? We're not violating physics here. There's no telepathy is, it's not like suddenly I could see behind a tree. What changes, at least in my case so far is, and you're right, it's hard to put into words. It's the direct, felt realness and solidity of what is implied by that visual data and that auditory data.
And prior to these experiences, I didn't even realize that my brain was interpreting everything through this lens because it was so automatic and it was just, well, I am me and that is the river, and that is a tree and that is a car that I wouldn't have been able to tell you that. There's two things going on there. There's the actual raw, direct subjective experience, and separately there's the interpretation of it. But then when one disappears, you sort of notice it. It's like, oh wait, what just happened?
We can think of Sean's two experiences as different depths of the same kind of insight process. In the first, the insight is experiencing awareness separated from thoughts. And the second, the insight is experiencing awareness separated from any sense of self interpreting the experience. Meditation teachers sometimes describe this as unhooking. A friend of mine named Pranab first encountered the idea through Michael Taft, a non-dual meditation teacher who we'll hear from later in the series.
Pranab: He has this thing of unhook from thought or let thoughts unhook from the mind. And that actually just happened as an experience where I realized, oh, all these thoughts are just these head and scalp sensations. And I remember one sit in September of 2021, I remember just sitting with a friend, and I remember feeling like, oh, I unhooked. And it stayed that way throughout the entire sit, I was just like, wait a minute. Whoa, it's super spacious. It's like my head feels like a bowling ball or a snow globe. And it just got all shaken up and smooth, and open and empty. And I don't think I'd ever felt that where thoughts were there, but they didn't have a grip on me.
And I think it just reformulated my whole experience of what it was like to think.
I heard this same kind of unhooking thing in a completely different context from a musician and poet who lives on Vancouver Island in Canada named Kim. She'd never practiced meditation, but her chiropractor recommended a simple technique.
Kim: He suggested that I find a spot to stare at on a wall, and then just notice my thoughts and imagine them coming at me like a flock of birds and then passing overhead and disappearing behind me. What I noticed was just the relief it was to not be blended with those thoughts, to have a practice that would unblend me from those thoughts. They weren't me, they were just a flock of birds coming and going.
And then what happened in my body when I was able to let that go is it was an experience of sort of different stories unhooking themselves. That's the part that's really hard to explain about this.
So I would watch, a narrative about death, and how death was just darkness in the end.
And I would go, oh, there's that. And then as it passed overhead, it was like I had a physical experience of that story unhooking.
And then after it passed and it unhooked, there was just space and curiosity left.
For Kim, unhooking wasn't just cerebral. It had this bodily and somatic side to it.
Kim: It was really interesting at first to notice that the muscle constriction was related and connected with those stories. So the terrible story would come and I would notice like my heart start to brace or my shoulders start to tighten. And in that experience of watching the thoughts, it was very plain to me that that was one way that I was keeping the stories going was the body constriction and as I soften the muscles in my body. Yeah, the stories began to unhook.
When Pranab described unhooking, he said it left him in a sense of spaciousness. So I asked Kim the same question. After her muscles relaxed and thoughts flew away, what changed?
Kim: I mean, you're asking me to wrap a language around something.
And language itself is rigid.
I think it was like a softening into not having to explain it.
A softening into, I don't know.
There was just this delightful falling into not knowing.
It was interesting that Kim used the word falling to describe what she felt, because in many of these accounts of insight experiences, you hear this same sense that we can't control them. We're not doing the insight. We're not making it happen. It feels like it just happens out of nowhere. It's like a flash of lightning. Remember how Sean spent 10 months after his experience on the airplane trying to have it again, but he couldn't, even though he knew exactly what to look for. And the same thing happened with Ben, a 31-year-old account manager in London:
Ben: Having had a few, like a few sort of interesting, powerful experiences. You just realize that you can't manufacture them. You don't know how they come other than the fact that you're just sitting quietly and you know that it sometimes does happen. But there's no formula. Not that I've, I've worked out anyway, of course.
And a filmmaker named Stuart.
Stuart: And I'm going through this experience and it feels totally liberating and I almost felt though I had no control, it was as if it was totally not my choice.
If insight experiences feel beyond our control, then in a way, we're at their mercy, for better or worse.
Just about every experience you'll hear in this series is a positive one, and that reflects what came up in my interviews and the skew of meditation experiences in general. But it's absolutely the case that these experiences can go wrong. Some pivot points can be terrifying in the moment because we have no idea what's happening.
Jay: It was very decentering and scary to be honest. Like it was just like, what's happening to me? Am I like losing my mind? Am I gonna be psychotic?
In Ben's case, not only did a lot of anxiety come up during meditation, he even started to actively have a panic attack while meditating.
Ben: I had not long, but quite intense short panic attacks basically. So to, to have a, a sort of quite horrible experience meditating, but to manage, to sort of stay, sat down and just go like, oh my God, this is awful. This is horrible. What's happening? But then also for a sort of a little voice, I guess, to be going, like it's gonna pass though. It's gonna pass, it's gonna pass. And it did pass. And I was able to sort of say stay, sat down in a meditation posture throughout was really interesting.
And Ben actually comes out of this experience glad that it happened.
Ben: I mean, it is funny because some people might hear this and think, well, you, you had a panic attack because you were meditating and you do go and touch sort of areas of your psyche or you kind of get below the layers of your normal day-to-day experience and you, you can get in contact with some difficult parts of your mind, body, you know, whatever you wanna call it. So yeah, I might not have had that experience if I hadn't meditated, but I'm very glad that I did. Interestingly enough. Yeah. Which I don't know, some people might find crazy, but it's, it was quite a, quite a formative experience for me.
You can think of these as challenging experiences. They're difficult in the moment, but resolve in the long run. But there are just plain bad meditation experiences that have no redeeming qualities. They can disrupt or destabilize someone's life, and they might regret having them altogether.
Of the 41 meditators I interviewed, I heard from one person who came out of it unsure if he was actually better off than before. His name was Michael.
Michael: And it was like, this is kind of bad. I don't know what's going on. I shouldn't meditate for a while. I did some sort of brain surgery that I wasn't wanting to do. I wish the warning labels were upfront, so if Buddha was like, here, I'm gonna teach you some extremely weird shit. And you might not want it, that would've been better, right.
Documenting the risks and harms of meditation is a much newer field in the West than studying the benefits. But Michael struggled with two of the main negative effects that are slowly being documented. The first was derealization, which is kind of like it sounds. The world can start to feel dreamlike or unreal.
Michael: Not that I didn't think I was real, 'cause I know I'm real, but like, you kind of feel like you're in a movie, you can't feel anything. Some people talk about that like observer feeling, you know, like. I'm watching myself do this, which you feel is not real.
The second was depersonalization, which was more of a sense of detachment from his emotions or his body. He says he still experiences this even long after the particular experiences he told me about came and went.
Michael: And I still miss this. I can't get caught up in anything right. So positive experiences typically don't feel as the same as the way that I remember them. They're not bad, but they're just shorter. Like the resonance of everything is way shorter. So there is, there was that feeling of like distance creeping in, of some of your observations like you were. Not actually like enjoying a thing. You were observing yourself enjoying a thing or something like that.
Michael's situation is kind of the inversion of a more common problem. More often, the issue that meditators are dealing with isn't how to get rid of the changes they don't want. It's how to make temporary changes permanent. How to stabilize the benefits they find in otherwise fleeting experiences. And my favorite story illustrating this struggle came from a man named Thomas.
Thomas: My name is Thomas. I am 53 years old, and I am a mid-level manager in the tech industry here in Denmark.
Thomas started meditating in his mid-20s back in 1998.
Thomas: I was 26 years old and life was pretty good. Wrapping up, college, had a job, was with my then girlfriend, now wife, then I've stumbled into uncovering repressed childhood memories.
Not the comfortable kind.
And I perceived them as blackness, darkness, like black holes in my psyche, really.
And in retrospect, I could see how they had guided my life's journey so far and helped me avoid certain things and, be attracted to other things. Not always healthy and wholesome.
And it, what really stood out to me, I was terrified that I would repeat the same pattern that was repeated on me as a child. That I, through not knowing, through being remote controlled by these black holes, that I would end up doing harm to the people I love the most.
And at that moment, I recalled enlightenment.
And without knowing anything more about it, it made sense that black holes, enlightenment, one's gotta be a fixed for the other. Let's go.
So before starting to really study this, I literally vowed: I will attain enlightenment. I need to, for my own pain and for the people around me.
And then I started to pick up the practice.
So he starts out of the gate practicing intensely, and almost right away starts noticing benefits.
Thomas: I found very early on that meditation had a profound impact on my wellbeing and also my cognitive abilities.
I was wrapping up college and I remember thinking, oh, I wish I had started on this five years ago. Studying was so much easier. I could focus, I could, reflect deeply in ways I couldn't before. So I very quickly, I saw benefits and, definitely increases in, life contentment, satisfaction.
But since Thomas was literally aiming at enlightenment, he knew he had a long road ahead. So he practiced for many years, and his first major insight moment didn't come until shortly after the birth of his first daughter.
Thomas: I would get on the baby stroller and go for walks in nature.
And those walks would be my meditation practice. So one day I got her in a stroller and walked out the door and down the usual road, and at one point, barely out the door, it was as if I, metaphorically speaking, stepped into a membrane it had rested every, it stopped everything for a fraction of a second, and then this membrane burst and as burst, the whole world just opened up for me.
I lacked, I, I severely lacked a vocabulary for this.
I wanted to be able to relate this. So I tried on words: Is this unity?
No, it's not. Unity indicates things united. There were no objects united, that didn't make sense.
So is it oneness? No. 'cause oneness would indicate, again, a thingness, an entity didn't make sense.
The only thing I could put words on was boundless. It felt boundless. And everything, the forest and the baby stroller and the foot and the thought was made of the same essential substance.
That's what it felt like. And very shortly after and seconds the thought came, this is it.
That's what they write about. This is it. This is enlightenment. This is what life will be like forever and ever.
That turned out to be a misled prediction.
One thing that really stood out to me in that moment was thoughts.
I had assumed there would be no thinking, no thoughts at all. But there was, however, something had definitely changed about thinking I could no longer place them, locate them inside a head. Because there was no inside, there was no outside either. That just, that didn't make sense.
I recall glancing up to look at a tree to check, can I see thoughts among the branches? I couldn't.
But I think it's pretty good image of how, surprised I was and how I just didn't have any bearings. What is this? What can I expect from here?
So thoughts were, were happening. They were clearly not owned by anybody. I was certainly not doing thinking. It just happened.
And I found the same with walking, still walking the the baby stroller. Nobody was doing it. It was just happening on its very own.
Were there qualities to the experience, like in the moment, was it a nice experience? Did it have affective qualities like that?
Thomas: It was immensely blissful, like a huge rush of energy. It was strange because it was extremely energetic and very calm at the same time. And so the non-dual view experiencing and the bliss lingered on for four or five days. I didn't sleep much in those days.
I simply couldn't.
But over those four or five days, it all began to fade.
Thomas: First the bliss started to fade. I was okay. But then this nondual view started to fade. And thought started to happen inside the head. And I was like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. This is not happening. That's what we agreed. The plan was: this was forever. That this is not how the story goes. But that was how the story went and it, it faded.
So he goes off and does a bunch of reading. He actually picks up the same headless way practice by Douglas Harding that Sean mentioned earlier. And over time, Thomas does figure out how to temporarily prompt these shifts, but they never stabilized. The experiences always came to an end.
Thomas: And I learned that I could basically replay, the shift so I could bring it online again and again.
And I figured, that has to be it, that, that's what Douglas Harding was saying. Just keep repeating the experience and it'll stabilize. It'll expand. It'll be self-sustaining. So I kept doing that and I kept at it for 19 years. And it didn't stabilize.
I had glimpses a second, a minute, an hour, sometimes a day, sometimes several days where I would linger in and out. It didn't stabilize. And what really bothered me was when I needed my practice the most, when life was tough, couldn't make the shift.
Just plain old suffering. Thomas and I couldn't get the support from my practice that I so wanted. It left me demotivated.
This is not the end of Thomas' story. It gets much more intense. But it goes beyond the scope of this series. So there is a bonus episode available where you can hear the rest of Thomas' story all the way through to his extended cessation, which is one of the highest attainments in some schools of Buddhism. But for now, in terms of our focus on initial pivot points, I want to point out one quality of Thomas' experience that we haven't heard anywhere else yet: bliss.
Thomas: It was immensely blissful.
Even though bliss can occasionally show up in insight experiences, it's a hallmark of the second bucket of pivot points, concentration experiences.
Evan Price dabbled in meditation in college.
Evan: Honestly, like months would pass. Maybe I meditate a couple times in that span just to sort of convince myself that I was maintaining my practice.
After he graduated, he finally had the time to get a bit more serious, so he signed up for a meditation retreat.
Evan: I signed up and, got on my bicycle and rode over to Vancouver Island and basically sat on a pillow for 11 hours a day in silent meditation.
And right away, he learned one of the first lessons that people encounter when they go on a retreat, which is that it can really physically hurt.
Evan: I mean, I'm no more suited to sitting on the ground than my grandma.
Really, my mobility is not good. And I was one of the lucky ones. I had the wall, so yeah, it's, it's just, that's physically painful.
So Evan dug in. He meditated, he felt the pain, he managed to get all the way through to the evening meditation on the eighth day of the 10-day retreat.
Evan: Of course my back is hurting. Of course it is. And right, you were doing the body scans up and down for the 100th time. My attention is beaming straight into my back, which is just screaming at me. And I sort of, I really, I felt like I un unclenched. I sort of, I don't know how or why none of us do. And the pain just dissolved.
It was amazing. I mean, it was completely, it was so insane that I spent the rest of that session just reeling. I was like, I have a superpower. I was amazed. One moment. Searing pain, genuine pain. And then the next moment, it was just like static, I will never forget the feeling of a very gross sensation, giving way to this fizz. It was amazing. And I was so lost for words that I scrambled up to the front of the room and just babbled at the, the head meditator for a second I don't even think I managed to articulate what the hell had just happened to me.
Pain suddenly giving way to something like a fizz comes up a lot in descriptions of concentration experiences. Here's Zen meditation teacher Henry Shukman, for example, describing his first meditation retreat.
Henry: The very first long retreat that I did, I was having a hellish time. And then towards the latter end of the retreat, suddenly having this absolutely crystal clear moment of seeing that I just wasn't there. There just was nobody on board. And the pain in my knee, which had been acute, just became an interesting tingle.
The transformation of searing pain into just a fizz, static, or tingle, can be jarring on its own. But for many, that's just the beginning.
Emily: My name is Emily Gullikson. I'm 27 years old. And I was a researcher, but I'm now a student.
Emily was about 16 when she was first introduced to meditation by her dad, who'd been going to a weekly mindfulness group.
Emily: I remember the first time I went with my dad to one of these groups. So the first time I sat for like half an hour with my eyes closed, I'd never done that before. I remember feeling like, oh, I feel kind of different. I remember feeling very big, like sort of expansive. So immediately that piqued my curiosity. I was like, oh, this is interesting. I feel like I could explore this more.
She started reading some meditation books and practicing a bit on her own. But one book in particular, Sam Harris' book titled Waking Up, told her that if you really want to get into the deeper stuff, you should go on a meditation retreat.
Emily: I was at the end of my gap year, so I wanted to like go to India, very cliche gap year thing to do. I booked myself onto one of the Indian Goenka retreat centers to do a 10 day retreat there. And, the whole thing was like, so hard, like so, so tough, but somehow managed to see it through to the end. I remember the first four days were like grueling, really tough, but by day six, day seven, some cool things started to happen. It was very physical, like dealing with a lot of physical pain.
So I think the majority of the meditation was how do I deal with this intense pain in my legs, in my back, everywhere?
The instructions at a Goenka retreat involve a lot of scanning your body, and zooming in to hold attention on one spot. So as her focus built up, she started really paying attention to the pain, and that's when things shifted.
Emily: It was like really focusing in on one point, like let's say there was a pain in my knee, really zooming in.
Just keeping my attention there and then suddenly something would unblock and it would turn into pleasure around my body, like waves of ecstasy going around my body.
And I remember thinking, this is crazy. I can turn pain into pleasure. Like they were like two sides of the coin.
I was just like, this is crazy. I would not have expected any of that to happen. I was just in awe at what was, what was going on.
I felt so, so much happiness, just like radiating out, in a way that, like, it did feel a little bit manic at times. So like, when I had to go to work, I was like, this is, I can't really work in this state.
But then it, it calmed down, you know, after that.
It turns out this is a really common pattern. Here's a 32-year-old named Aaron also describing a meditation retreat.
Aaron: And then, yeah, I just had this at some point sitting with lots and lots of pain, sitting cross-legged. Pain in one of my legs. And then in an instant it just transformed into piti, like into pleasure. I didn't move, nothing moved, like nothing changed about the, physical world, so to speak. But like whatever the sensation, this intense sensation of pain, it just transformed into pleasure. Very intense pleasure. I think that was the first time I ever had piti like that. Just like intense, like it felt like an MDMA, I don't know, 150 milligrams of MDMA or something. And I was really like, it felt like really high.
That was, that was really striking. I remember like after the sit, going to the washroom and feeling like, wow, like I'm so high right now.
That word that Aaron used a few times, pīti, is a Pali word usually translated as rapture.
It describes this kind of intense and effervescent feeling of pleasure in the body, kind of like the butterflies in your stomach when you drop on a rollercoaster. Pīti is often associated with a certain kind of meditation known as jhana. But to talk about that, we should meet Max.
Max: So my name is Max. I am 34 years old and I'm a software engineer.
I think it was October of 2019. And I was going through a pretty rough time back then. And I'd been in therapy for quite a while then, and I picked up meditation as an adjunctive therapy because I'd heard many great things about using meditation as an adjunct to therapy. So I suppose first off, I just wanted to have my depression go away and this was one of the ways to make that happen.
Max tries a couple of meditation apps, but he's eventually pointed to a meditation book titled The Mind Illuminated, or TMI.
Max: And since I'm a software engineer and a pretty nerdy person, getting a 500 page manual that tells you how to sit still seems like the thing to do. So I did that.
Max starts getting good traction with his practice. He can hold his attention on his breath longer and longer, which is one of the markers of progress in the early stages. And he starts to find that his strengthened concentration is surfacing buried emotions.
Max: This was more or less the first time in my life that I had ready access to like the things that were going on below the surface of my thoughts. Like suddenly there were emotions coming up where I wasn't actively thinking about them, but I was like super inactively, not thinking about them. You know? And that's something that if you are living a more or less modern distracted lifestyle just does not come up by itself. And meditation was giving me access to that. It felt like I got free therapy in between my therapy sessions every time I sat down on, on, on the cushion.
Max keeps coming back to the practice. And in early 2020, just before the pandemic hit, Max goes on a holiday weekend to a cabin in the woods with his friends. Has a great time, and on the way back, he's driving, he's alone, he's kind of bored, so he figures, why not meditate?
Max: Driving is usually a very boring thing. So there's one thing you can do with attention, which is the new trick you just learned. And I did that. While of course keeping my eyes on the road, try to see how much of my attention I could spare and just like, put on the breath. And I think it was like half an hour into the long drive back home, I was suddenly starting to like really get into the groove of it and suddenly I was feeling very tingly and it was building and building and building over the course of just like a minute or so. I was like almost shaking, while I was driving because there was just this physical excitement and energy and bliss just happening and coursing from my whole body.
And, again, I didn't know what this was. I didn't know like, there's a name for this. And, I pulled over. I pulled over and just like calmed down for a second and thought, what the hell was this?
When Max gets home, he pores over his TMI meditation manual and takes to the internet, searching for clues as to what had just happened. And pretty quickly, he comes across a description of almost exactly what he experienced, this overflowing bodily sense of buzzing bliss as the first of a series of eight meditative states of absorption, known in Buddhism as the jhanas. Now, we could do a whole series on the jhanas, but for now, we can just say that they're deepening states of concentration or absorption. The first jhana is characterized by this kind of buzzing, pleasurable energy that consumes the body and engulfs awareness. And as you proceed through the jhanas, you're progressively refining that concentration, and the bliss gives way to a more relaxed and simplified state.
One very surprising thing about jhanas is that the instructions for getting into them aren't all that complicated, at least in theory, which is why people like Max keep stumbling into them by accident.
Max: I was enraptured by how insane it seemed.
And also by the fact that I had just experienced this thing, which otherwise would've been completely outside of my, my, my window of what I thought was possible and plausible.
Max found instructions for accessing the first jhana online, and they worked. He was able to keep practicing the same experience.
So remember when we talked about control earlier, this is a big difference between insight and concentration. It seems that you actually can have some control over concentration.
Max: So I found those instructions and I tried them and I could replicate it, and these were like things from two and a half thousand years ago, which I had, up until that point, only thought as, okay, these are some crazy religious people from essentially prehistoric times. Like they didn't even have writing then. Like there's no way anything that's in those old scriptures has any bearing on my modern reality. And here I am, they're giving me instructions on how I can put my brain into this weird mode and experience bliss. And it just works. Like what?
I heard from a lot of meditators who came across the jhanas one way or another, and gathering their various descriptions was admittedly a lot of fun. Samuel, for example, who works in occupational health and safety, overheard someone talking about the jhanas at a meditation retreat. So he found a book on jhana practice by Leigh Brasington titled Right Concentration: A Practical Guide to the Jhanas. Sam finds what I think many people find when they read Leigh's book, which is that the instructions are very clear and practically arranged, so he decides to try them out.
Samuel: About a week or two weeks after the the retreat ended, I was sitting in meditation. The instruction that Leigh Brasington gives is to get to a point of stillness of what he calls access concentration, where the mind is pretty calm and still, you're still aware of sensations and thoughts and feelings. And then from there, you change your, point of focus from your breath to something pleasurable in the body. And so for me, I, I never really had what I would consider anything pleasurable, but I did have this tingling sensation that would come up. Usually in my hands. And I think he noted somewhere that tingling is also under that definition of pleasure.
So yeah, at one point during a meditation session, I think it was at night. Yeah, it was right before I went to bed. I'm in the access concentration point. And then I switched my focus to this tingling sensation in my hands. And continue to breathe. And so this tingling sensation starts to grow and expand from my hands, like into my arms and then into my chest. And there's also a pleasure sensation associated with that tingling sensation that starts to arise. And it starts to like build up, build up, sort of feels like a volcano starting to erupt. And basically all of a sudden it like shoots up through my head and lasts for a couple seconds, and then just whatever it was, was like way too intense for me.
My heart was racing, I was sweating. I just wasn't able to sustain it. But I was also like, I think too scared too to go down that path, whatever it was. And I, I remember going to bed that night, just like took me a while to go to sleep. Just 'cause I was like so excited and amazed and like, what just happened? This is real. Like what he's talking about is like real, these altered states.
It's not the case that all roads of concentration lead to blissful altered states. Concentration stills the mind. It simplifies the busyness, and that can lead to deeply relaxing or wonderful experiences. But we've also already heard that it can do something else.
Max described his early meditation as giving him access to emotions buried beneath the surface of his thoughts, which is why it was so helpful as a complement to therapy. A common metaphor in contemplative traditions is to think of the mind as an agitated lake with ripples all across the surface. And concentration lets the whole thing settle so that you can see deeper into the lake.
And sometimes what happens is whatever's buried down there becomes visible from the surface. That experience wasn't the center of Max's story, but for others it can be.
Jay: My parents immigrated to Canada from India and have a deep like kind of rural Indian Hinduism.
This is Jay, a 41-year-old author and technology designer.
Jay: So unlike a lot of people in the West that I've encountered, this stuff was never esoteric and like sort of strange eastern practice for me. It was more like a family heirloom. So I was exposed to it, watching my father meditate, and we went to Hindu temples and did rites and rituals since I was very young. It was a lame thing that my parents did that I didn't understand and I rolled my eyes at it mostly.
Nevertheless, Jay took a class on Hinduism and Buddhism in college, which got him interested in meditation. And eventually, the singer in Jay's band went off on a meditation retreat.
Jay: But when he came back and like he came back and he was. Not smoking anymore. He wasn't drinking, he went vegetarian. His voice sounded better, which was like meant a lot to me as the drummer in his band. And I was like, okay, I need, it's time to stop talking. Like literally and figuratively, right? So then I signed up and I went on my retreat and that was a absolutely transformative experience.
Jay signed up for the same kind of 10-day Goenka retreat that we've already heard others go on.
Jay: I'm doing this practice and, you know, first few days I'm just really profoundly uncomfortable in my body, like sitting on the floor. So I'm like trying to get all these pillows and trying to like set up these pillows and create my little fortress of comfort. And this was around the time Goenka, I think it's like halfway through the retreat, Goenka recommends adhitthana, which is like strong determination sitting like, we're gonna do an hour practice. But this is a special practice for us to bring a lot of determination to the practice. Like to sit really still and to try to stay with the breath and the body.
And so in that practice, the determination I said was, I'm gonna just get rid of all these pillows and I'm just gonna have one pillow and I'm gonna sit there, whatever may come, right?
So Jay dismantles the fortress of pillows. The hour-long sit begins. And for the first time in Jay's meditation practice, things start to get really intense.
Jay: So I sat there and the pain started to come and I started to notice all kinds of powerful insights in this like crucible of sensitivity. And then something kind of like unlocked and I had this like extremely vivid memory.
Of the last time I was in India after my grandfather had died and my father was taking me around his ancestral village. And I went to that house and all the furniture is got out of my grandfather's house. It's totally empty, but on the wall of his shelf, there's this picture of my brother and I, and then all these other memories start to happen. Like I remember when my mom called me to tell me that he had died. I remember I was in an abandoned factory, like drinking all the time and trying to meet girls playing music. And I remember not even being able to grieve, I was so numb and I just started to like, well, up in the meditation retreat with tears.
All this emotion was coming up and I was con, my, my conceptual mind was confused. Like, why is this all coming up? And like all of this stuff was happening. And I sat still in this almost perfect meditation posture, letting the discomfort flow through me till the end of the hour. And then I heard Goenka's, deep Indian accent like, take rest, take rest. You know, like, just like to end the session. I was like, tears down my face. I get up. And I go for a walk and I could feel so much more. I was so much less numb. And I felt so much lighter.
And I realized like then my conceptual mind came back in and I was like, oh, this is what meditation is about. I was holding an emotion that was encoded several years before that when I saw that picture of myself in my deceased grandfather's house in India. There was some encoded feeling that I was, that I was too scared to feel That I just repressed down there. And like years later, on the side of a mountain, halfway around the world in a retreat center in British Columbia, the process of meditation, sublimated that emotion, allowed me to see it clearly and like so much less numb. So much lighter.
Can you imagine why after an experience like that, I would spend the rest of my life like going on retreats and meditating, and even devoting my career to meditation. I was like, oh, this is profound healing that so many of us need and that I needed more of. And that was a profound turning point for me in terms of the origin of the deeper side of my practice.
Both categories of pivot point, insight and concentration, have all kinds of subcategories within them, and you could certainly find experiences that don't fit either category all that well. Or that fit both well enough that it's not clear which label they'd fall under. I'm a lot less interested in trying to find some taxonomy that perfectly categorizes all the different kinds of pivot points, than I am looking at what they all share across their differences.
And in the first episode, when I defined a pivot point as a gateway into the world of deep meditation, that idea of a gateway is one of those commonalities. These experiences are where things start getting weird, start getting transformative. It's like setting foot on an undiscovered continent, and these experiences are just those first few steps where you realize how large and unknown to you the surrounding area is.
Claudia: That first retreat experience gave me one insight into what was possible for meditation. And this was like my, oh my God, however much you think there is, there is so much more.
People don't come away from pivot points with a whole bunch of answers about the nature of the mind or the mechanics of wellbeing. They don't come away permanently transformed into an enlightened being. But they do have this newfound sense, or belief, that there is something significantly deeper and more profound and more consequential on offer through meditation than the mild stress relief that the popular narratives of mindfulness have described.
Sean: Now in hindsight, I've also realized even those glimpses, were kind of just scratching the surface, right? Everything I've experienced so far indicates it is a process and there are layers to it, and it's gradual. And if I extrapolate, I could see how that could completely change someone's actual life, right? Like their, their moment to moment lived experience, their reactivity, whether they feel threatened by things, whether they fear death. Like everything could be completely turned on its head if that rabbit hole is as deep as it looks like it maybe is.
Kati: Every time I've been able to see a kind of distant vista of what might be possible in practice, the experience was not what I was expecting. And what was revealed is vistas upon vistas upon vistas that I couldn't even see before.
This is Kati Devaney, who has a PhD in neuroscience and is currently the science director for a foundation that funds consciousness research.
Kati: And some of the outcomes I've had from meditation practice have just been literally inconceivable to me prior to having them. And I think the more ways that we can talk about these things with as much different language as possible, the more people this will be accessible to. I think it's very conceivable that what is happening along a path of practice are quantifiable changes in the psychobiology of people. And when we know what those changes are, we can develop all sorts of methods to make those changes more accessible to more people.
What Kati's describing, studying the psychobiological changes in meditators who have these kinds of transformative experiences, all in the hopes of making them more accessible, this is exactly what the field of meditation science is just starting to do. So in the next episode, which I think of as the science episode, we're gonna hear from the scientists working on the frontiers of advanced meditation research.
We'll move from hearing what pivot points are like, to why meditation causes them, what they're doing to the mind, and what they can teach us about consciousness.
If you wanna learn more about the series, head over to pivotpoints.xyz. There you can find transcripts, guest information, and links to more material.
I'll be publishing bonus episodes and collections of short clips that didn't make it into the series through my newsletter, which you can subscribe to at heretodisappear.com. And if you'd like to support the series, you can become a paid subscriber of that newsletter or share the series with a friend.
Pivot Points is supported by the Waking Up meditation app, edited by Amy Standen, original theme music by Marcus Bagala, cover art by Valero Doval, mixed by Lucas Del Calvo, created and hosted by Oshan Jarow, and made possible by the generous meditators willing to share their weird experiences for public listening. Thank you all.