What’s a Pivot Point?
The gateway experiences from a beginner’s meditation practice into the deep end are extremely strange.
Claudia thought transformative meditation experiences were for monks. Then she felt the little person living behind her eyeballs disappear, and was forced to reconsider. Matt, a lawyer, was skeptical of all the radical claims Buddhists make about meditation. Then his mind flipped inside out, and he found his evidence.
Every now and then, meditators have these experiences — pivot points — that completely change their understanding of meditation, consciousness, and occasionally, life in general. And even as meditation grows more popular in the West, most attention remains fixed on beginner’s mindfulness and stress-relief. In this series, we’ll investigate the strange, profound, and transformative world of pivot points. It’s going to be a lot of fun.
Extras
-
Coming soon Every Single Pivot Point For reasons concerning the human preference for order over chaos, I could not include each of the 40 pivot points people shared with me in the series. Here, you’ll find every single transformative experience I heard, arranged one climax after another, without my commentary.
Transcript
Claudia: I had like done bits and bobs. Like I would download the Headspace app and do 20 minutes a day and do breath focus and all that kind of stuff. And that was very much in that, you know, oh, meditation for stress reduction, that kind of thing.
This is Claudia, a health and science journalist. And like millions of Americans, she first picked up meditation for the practical benefits.
Claudia: If I sit and meditate for 20 minutes, I'll feel better afterwards. Like, I'll feel calmer. I'll know my heart rate will have decreased, I'll probably sleep better, all these things. But it was very much like I have to go through the boring thing sitting and counting my breath, and it's dull.
The popularity of basic mindfulness over the past decade or two has spread this story of meditation as a tool for stress reduction.
And that's all true. A little meditation can be a nice and relaxing thing.
But for thousands of years across different traditions, the stories that have been told about what meditation can do have centered around claims of deep psychological transformation: Fundamental shifts in how we experience ourselves and the world, astounding insights into the nature of the mind, and huge boosts in wellbeing.
In Claudia's case, she'd taken a course on Buddhism in college, so she was aware of these deeper claims, but they didn't feel relevant for her practice as a contemporary Western person with a career and a family.
Claudia: I knew intellectually because I've been exposed to it, that there was this incredible richness of meditation outside of that. But I guess I thought, oh, that's for people who are willing to commit their lives to this stuff. You know? I kind of thought, this is for people who were gonna change their name to something from like the Pali language and, spend years and years and years in a monastery. And I knew that was never going to be me.
But it was, in fact, going to be her.
Claudia did not change her name and go live in a monastery, but she did have a transformative meditation experience that led to things she never thought were possible for her, and completely blew open the kind of practice she understood meditation to be.
Claudia: I get back home and I have a really, like challenging Christmas. It's the first one where my mom who had just died wasn't there. Me and my family were all just like feeling horrible. And I went back from my family home in the north of England, came back to London where I live. And I sat down and literally had the thought: I am gonna get somewhere with this. I was like, I am going to get somewhere today. Because I need something. Like, that was this awful experience and I'm gonna crack something today.
So Claudia goes to the citadel of contemporary meditation teachings, YouTube.
Claudia: And I just typed in non-dual meditation. And I clicked on the first thing that came up. It was like a 15 minute meditation. And I just sat down and started following along, and then the guy narrating it just goes: How do you know you have a head?
And something just, I had this intense experience of feeling what felt like the little person, the little me in my head, sitting behind my eyes and controlling everything. I had this incredible visual of that person just like going back and going down my neck And just like disappearing into the cavernous blackness of the inside of my body. And just joining the rest of my being.
I just started to cry because I just had this feeling of oh my God, they're right. All these podcasts I'd listen to with people being like. You know who you really are is not this little gremlin in your head telling you to like, be better and do the things and, hey, do you remember when that girl was mean to you? And you were 10 and all this nonsense? And I was just like, oh my God, they're fucking right. And it was just the most incredible, revelatory experience. And I was like in shock. It was the first time I really understood missionary religion where I was like, I need to go and tell everyone.
Claudia's is not an isolated experience. Sometimes on purpose, sometimes by surprise, all kinds of meditators are discovering these experiences that completely change how they think about meditation. And more importantly, that completely change the ways they believe it's possible to feel. They change their understanding of how their minds work, or can work.
Claudia: In my culture where I live, people don't know about this. People think of meditation in this head spacey, stress reduction way, but like. Oh my God. You can feel like you are on fantastic MDMA guys. Like, did you know?
I'm Oshan Jarow. I'm a writer and journalist. And this is episode one of Pivot Points, a podcast series about transformative meditation experiences.
I've been around meditation one way or another for most of my life. My father was a professor of religion with a focus on Indian traditions. So growing up, our house was filled with meditators of all stripes. I've had my own meditation practice on and off for about 12 years now, and I've been all over the map. At times, I've thought of meditation as one of the most important practices of my life. I've also gone through phases of seeing it as mostly a navel-gazing waste of my time.
As a journalist, I've spent years covering the science and growing culture of meditation in the West. And through that time, something I've seen over and over is that Claudia's discovery of this whole other world of meditation experience, one that goes well beyond anything that the popular story of mindfulness and stress relief covers, is surprisingly common.
But at the same time, the popular stories our culture tells about what meditation is still haven't updated to reflect that.
Instead, we have these two seemingly separate worlds of meditation. There's the world of beginner's mindfulness, which is in the cultural spotlight, and then there's this whole other obscure world of deep meditation or advanced meditation. And even though all the really interesting, exciting stuff happens in the latter world of deep meditation, most of our attention has gone to the former world of beginner's mindfulness. So as both a meditator and a journalist, I've spent a lot of time thinking about the boundaries between these two worlds. What is it that separates the hundreds of millions of Westerners who engage with meditation apps and mindfulness and think about it all as a form of stress relief, from the people who think about meditation as one of the most profound and transformative practices in their lives?
Because it's not a matter of how much time you've spent meditating. You can launch into the deep end in your first 10 hours of practice ever, or it could take 10 years before anything remotely transformative happens.
What does seem to separate the two worlds of meditation, and determine the kind of thing someone understands meditation to be, is whether they've had a direct experience that showed them, firsthand, how weird it can get. How fundamentally meditation can change your mind.
And the more I've researched these kinds of experiences, or glimpses, the more they've coalesced into a single category, which I've started calling pivot points.
You can think of pivot points as meditation experiences that people would describe not as relaxing, but transformative. And for this series, I'm specifically interested in the first pivot point, the first time that someone has a meditation experience that changes what they think is possible. Because that's where we get this jump between the two worlds of meditation.
There's no single description for what these experiences are like. They might feel like insights into some obscure but fundamental aspect of the mind. They might feel like a sudden eruption of bliss across your entire field of awareness. They might involve the usual anchors of experience, like a sense of self or space or time, temporarily vanishing.
And while the majority of these experiences tend to be positive, they can also be destabilizing, dissociative, or just generally terrible.
But whatever the details of someone's particular experience, pivot points do have a few common threads.
They're completely unlike anything we're used to experiencing. They're sharp breaks from our ordinary habits of perception. And because of that, they tend to feel anything from confusing and shocking, to exciting or compelling. They're often described as feeling like discoveries.
And even though people will often describe these experiences as some of the most significant experiences in their lives, they're really difficult to talk about. And contemplative traditions have generally cautioned against putting too much focus on them.
As a result, we in the West know surprisingly little about them.
So this series is gonna focus directly on pivot points, which I think of as gateways from a beginner's meditation practice into the deep end.
Last summer, I put out a survey across the internet to see if I could find meditators who've had these experiences and who'd be up for recording a conversation about them.
Alex: And it feels like I am on literally the best super drug known to man. That was a life-changing moment for me, to recognize that, I didn't know that you could feel like that.
Emily: And that was by far the most crazy. Like it just got so, really far beyond what I thought was possible.
Charlie: Just a sense of my whole body having been almost like a fire hose had just been put up through my entire system and totally cleaned out. And I was left in shock amazement.
So the first step in this series, picking up in episode two, is gonna be hearing these stories directly from meditators to help answer the question: What does a pivot point feel like?
But my goal isn't just to collect a bunch of weird meditation reports. If you've ever had the pleasure of listening to a friend excitedly tell you about the weird dream they had, you'll know that reports of other people's weird experiences can get boring very quickly. The reason I wanna focus on pivot points is that even though they may be most interesting and impactful to the people having them, I think they're informative for all of us. There's a lot we can learn from them about deepening a meditation practice, but also deepening our understanding of how the mind works.
So to that end, I also interviewed scientists who study advanced meditation, who we'll hear from in episode three, and meditation teachers who've seen thousands of these experiences play out across their students. We'll hear from them in episode four. And in episode five, we'll take a step back to ask what comes after a pivot point? Or as a meditator named Carla put it:
Carla: So what, that's my big question all the time. So what. I had the explosive love experience, you know, so what.
How does that change somebody's life?
Some contemplative traditions have concepts that are similar to pivot points. Theravada Buddhism has stream entry, which is the first of their four stages of awakening. It's traditionally defined as an experience that destroys three things: the meditator's belief in their existence as a separate self, their doubt in the Buddhist teachings, and the idea that rigid adherence to doctrinal rules and rituals will bring about awakening.
Zen has kensho, which is a sudden falling away of your identification as a separate self, discovering an underlying unitary experience that Zen calls your original nature.
So both stream entry and kensho refer to very particular kinds of experience. There's a set of criteria, and if your experience doesn't fit the profile, it doesn't count. Pivot points aren't as strict in their criteria. They're a much broader category that can include very different kinds of experience. Tibetan Buddhism talks about nyams or special meditation experiences, altered states that sometimes arise over the course of practice. These can be blissful and exciting, and a nyam could certainly be a pivot point. But a meditator can have any number of nyams. There's no distinction for the first one. So pivot points defined as someone's first transformative meditation experience, isn't really a well-established concept.
Which is why I wanted to talk to meditators, scientists, and teachers. Because each perspective fills in a different part of the picture.
The meditators tended to describe pivot points as these exciting moments where they discovered that there's actually something to all of this crazy stuff they might have heard about meditation.
Sean: The sense of a pivot point.
Was this moment of, holy crap, this is real. Because again, I knew that there was something there objectively. But I was giving benefit of the doubts to all of these descriptions, which can sound quite, unscientific or extremely vulnerable to the entire list of psychological fallacies and, you know, self delusion and all of that confirmation bias. So I think regardless of trying to be open-minded and regardless of being motivated to find something that I logically knew was there, there was always this very strong skepticism. Until this moment of actually directly experiencing this.
Max: The first pivot point is probably the one where, like me, people are gonna say, well, I've been using this car here for like 20 or 30 something years, and suddenly I push a button and there's like wings come out and I think, oh, it could do this.
Scientists describe pivot points as experiences that change how the mind constructs our experience of the world.
For example, here's Ruben Laukkonen, a cognitive scientist and director of the Flourishing Intelligence Program at the University of Oxford.
Ruben: I would describe a pivot point as a major restructuring in the models that underlie our understanding of the world, ourselves and experience.
Ruben described the mind as a house of cards and pivot points as experiences that reach down into those lower levels, pluck out a card, and force everything it was holding up to rebuild in a way that makes room for this new experience.
Ruben: It's not such a big impact on that House of cards. If you take cards off the top of the deck and you replace them with new cards, you can gradually do that, and change the deck of cards that way. But it is a big deal if you pull out one of the cards at the bottom of that. That house that you've constructed. Because basically the whole thing comes, crashing down and when it reemerges, it doesn't reemerge in the same way that it was just a moment prior, to that important realization. And so I think a pivot point is when the meditation practice hits us somewhere deep enough that our understanding of reality has to change.
What was really fun about this project was hearing the echoes of the same ideas across perspectives. So when I asked the Zen meditation teacher Henry Shukman whether he's noticed any patterns across all of his students who've had these kinds of experiences.
Henry: Yeah, I'd say there's a common theme, which is some variation of oh my gosh, I've been wrong.
About whatever it is, about an emotion I thought I had to feel, or a thought pattern that I just couldn't shake off. Or, some discovery that the perspective I've had. Was not the only way of looking at life.
In other words, just like Ruben described, your understanding of what reality is, and what reality can be, changes.
So to help demonstrate what a pivot point is, there's one more story I wanna tell you about a lawyer from Iowa.
Matt: My name is Matt James. I am 50 years old and I am an attorney working in the realm of contracts.
Growing up, Matt read a few books on Buddhism, mostly out of curiosity. He didn't try to actually start meditating himself until well into adulthood when his job had started to grind him down.
Matt: I was a prosecutor. In Illinois, and that was a very stressful job. Dealing with, criminals and putting people in jail potentially. And I dealt a lot with victims of crime, which made it even more stressful. So, you know, overall, I just started to get depressed, and feel down. I was drinking a lot. I was watching a lot of television and just trying to cope. And I remember just sitting down one day and I'm like, I just, I can't do this anymore. I gotta change something. And I remembered back to when I had read those books about meditation and I thought, well, why don't I give this a shot and see how it goes.
So Matt decides to try meditating, and he proceeds to have an incredibly common experience.
Matt: It was terrible. It was awful. It was so boring. And all these thoughts in my head and I couldn't sit still, for more than a few minutes. And a lot of it was just me just sitting there checking the time. I think the first meditation I did, five minutes, I thought it was like five years. It seemed like an eternity. I did not have any wonderful experiences. I had a lot of boredom, a lot of discomfort, and a lot of thinking.
But remember, Matt was not in a good place, so he stuck with it. And even in those early days when the practice itself was terrible and boring, he was finding just enough benefit to keep going.
Matt: Even if you're not a very good meditator, your mind will start to calm and settle down. Just following through with the meditation and the instructions, and so on. So I saw that there was something there, that was worth pursuing a little bit more,
But even so, Matt was still a lawyer which meant he was skeptical of the claims Buddhism made about what deeper practice could actually do for him.
Matt: I don't believe anything that I'm told. You know, period. I'm a lawyer too, so I always need to see, I always need to see it. For example, in Theravada they talk about the no self. And you know, how the self is an illusion, but my issue was well then, but what? What's seeing all this? You know, if there's no self, what am I like, am I like a rock or a sponge or something? It doesn't make any sense.
So Matt goes on in this pattern for years, with the meditation slightly calming his mind, but the bigger claims about the more transformative stuff just not making any sense, until he goes on a meditation retreat in West Virginia.
The meditation center was in a quiet, rural setting, and while everyone was silently meditating indoors, a neighbor started doing yard work.
Matt: There was a farmer next door who would occasionally bring out the chainsaw. Or had a dog barking. And I was listening to these things and I was getting aggravated. It's like I'm meditating. Can somebody go tell that person to be quiet? And the usual habit is this is a problem, but then what is, quote, the problem becomes the helper to boost you up, through whatever you're working with. And what I had realized was I was hearing sound, but the sound wasn't taking place at the location of my ears. And it, that's where your eardrum is, right? Like your ear is pumping.
That's where the sound is entering the body. But I could hear the sound off in the distance over there. And I started switching between the two. It's like, how can this be? My ears are here and the sound is over there. It then just in a flash, everything reversed. So instead of becoming a person in space listening to external sounds coming in.
It was like it flipped. It just happened spontaneously and it's kind of like, foreground background reversal. So the spacious awareness that was in the background was suddenly in the foreground. And the objects all seemed, rather than me looking at an object, it was like all these objects were just arising in this spaciousness. And at the middle of it there wasn't a person there. It was, well, this is no self. Oh, okay. So, you know,
This was Matt's pivot point. And like Claudia's, it completely changed pretty much on the spot what he understood meditation to be and the kind of stuff he believed it could do.
Matt: But it, oh my gosh, it was amazing. Because you can have these concepts about what no self is. Or about what a meditation experience would be like. But those are just concepts. Those are just words on a page and mental images you're creating in your mind. When it arises, it's unlike everything that you've heard about. It's like waking up from the Matrix. It's like everything you've been told is not true. What you thought was real is a dream. My mind was so blown because I wasn't expecting it and it was so visceral, it was so vivid and it was so undeniable that I thought, how could I have ever existed in any other way?
Afterwards, Matt's experience of what meditating is like opened up into a far stranger palette of experiences than the calm of mindfulness.
Matt: This is the retreat where I started to have a lot of involuntary movements, a lot of energetic sensations. A lot of what you would call the temporary meditation experiences that people, we often get addicted to, like the candy of meditation. And, this is when I saw really, that we were dealing with something very deep and very profound and very true that could be experienced directly. And strangely enough, looking back at my notes, 'cause I think back on this as a pivot in my meditation practice, this is where I went from a meditation hobbyist, a person who did this from time to time to like, oh my God, this is like something that people can actually dedicate their lives to.
This is important and this is very serious.
Every one of my interviews were stories like Matt's or Claudia's, where people start out thinking that their meditation practice will never be anything other than mildly relaxing. Then they have a pivot point, and afterwards, they've flipped to thinking of their meditation practice as a much more profound one.
To be transparent about my own interest in this project, as a meditator, I've always been fascinated by these experiences because of how they seem to dispel any doubt in the deep and transformative value of meditation practice. Because the longer that I've meditated, the more I've had that sense of doubt creep into my own practice. It's not that I'm unsure whether these experiences are real or if deep meditation can really transform one's mind. I think that becomes pretty clear when you spend time around meditation communities or these days just on the right subreddit. And some of the experiences we'll hear in this series are ones that I've had myself.
But I've struggled with the question of whether these transformations of mind are really worth spending so much of my time meditating.
Because in a sense, everything you do transforms your mind in ways small and occasionally large. So what's so special, so worthwhile about the kinds of changes that deep meditation offers?
In a way, where you fall on this question, whether you're convinced of the particular value of the way that meditation can transform your mind, has always been a dividing line between the two worlds of meditation.
In the Tibetan Buddhist Mahamudra tradition, there's a 16th century practice manual titled Clarifying the Natural State. And right at the outset, it addresses itself to, quote, "Those who have had the occasion to believe. That phrase has stuck with me through this whole project: occasions to believe. Contemplative traditions all have to deal with this question: How do you generate belief in the value of the practice?
Contemporary Buddhist monks like Bhikkhu Bodhi have pointed out the role of faith in the Buddha's teachings. Bodhi writes that in Buddhist scripture, "The faculty of faith provides the element of inspiration and aspiration, which steers the mind away from the quagmire of doubt."
And in predominantly Buddhist cultures, faith in the Buddha's teachings, in the value of deep meditation, is a widespread cultural practice. But in the West, we have a different situation.
We lean on empirical evidence and science rather than religious traditions. Doubt and falsifiability are wired into our culture. And until very recently, the science of meditation has mostly focused on the world of beginner's mindfulness. So we don't have a bunch of research on which to base our belief in what deep meditation can do.
So the question that I've been wrestling with in my own practice, maybe unsurprisingly, has become a question behind this whole series. How do people in the West become convinced of the value of deep meditation?
If not faith, what are our occasions to believe?
The most common, compelling, and yet neglected answer that I've come across is pivot points.
And this series is a project of trying to learn everything we can about them, starting with, what do they feel like? When someone has an experience that completely changes what they think about meditation, what are they actually experiencing?
In the next episode, we'll take that question to the meditators.
If you wanna learn more about the series, head over to pivotpoints.xyz. There you can find transcripts, guest information, and links to more material. I'll be publishing bonus episodes and collections of short clips that didn't make it into the series through my newsletter, which you can subscribe to at heretodisappear.com. And if you'd like to support the series and more projects like this, you can become a paid subscriber of my newsletter or just share the series with a friend.
Pivot Points is supported by the Waking Up meditation app. Edited by Amy Standen. Original theme music by Marcus Bagala. Cover art by Valero Doval. Mixed by Lucas Del Calvo. Created and hosted by Oshan Jarow.
And made possible by the generous meditators willing to share their weird experiences for public listening. Thank you all.